Estimated monthly cost comparison — not just the headline price
Gusto and Jira do different jobs, so this is not a like-for-like comparison. The prices below are shown side by side for reference only; compare what each tool does before comparing cost.
Prices change often — confirm on the vendor's site before buying. Report incorrect pricing →
Quick Take
Different tools for different jobs — no cost winner
Based on advertised price plus documented recurring fees, not your exact usage.
Best for Gusto
Payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small businesses. Base at $40/mo + $6/person/mo, but benefits
Best for Jira
Atlassian's issue and project tracker, the industry standard for software teams. Free for 10 users,
Payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small businesses. Base at $40/mo + $6/per...
Advertised
$40
/month
Estimated monthly cost
$86
/month (illustrative)
Per-Person Fee Scaling
Simple plan: $40/mo + $6/person. Plus: $80/mo + $12/person. Premium: $180/mo + $22/person. A 25-pers...
Benefits Administration Add-On
Health insurance, 401(k), and benefits administration are not included in Simple. Plus plan ($80/mo ...
State Tax Registration Fees
Registering for state taxes in new states costs $35-$100 per state as a one-time fee. Multi-state re...
Atlassian's issue and project tracker, the industry standard for software teams....
Advertised
$8.15
/month
Estimated monthly cost
$546.15
/month (illustrative)
10-User Free Tier Ceiling
Free plan caps at 10 users with limited storage (2GB) and no audit logs. Team of 11 must jump to Sta...
Marketplace Add-On Stacking
Most teams need 3-5 Marketplace apps (Tempo Timesheets $10/user, Zephyr Scale $10/user, BigPicture $...
Admin & Configuration Overhead
Jira's flexibility is a curse — workflow customization, permission schemes, and field configurations...
Cloud vs Data Center Pricing Confusion
Atlassian sunsetted Server licenses. Data Center starts at $42,000/yr (500 users). Cloud Enterprise ...
Premium Feature Gate
Advanced Roadmaps, IP allowlisting, sandbox environments, and 99.9% SLA require Premium at $16/user/...
Gusto advertises $40/mo. Jira advertises $8.15/mo.
Gusto has 3 documented hidden fees. Jira has 5.
Gusto confidence: 76%. Jira confidence: 82%.
| Metric | Gusto | Jira | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advertised Price | $40/mo | $8.15/mo | Jira |
| Estimated Monthly Cost | $86/mo | $546.15/mo | — |
| Recurring Extra Fees | +$46/mo | +$538/mo | Gusto |
| One-Time Costs | $50 | $0 | Jira |
| # Documented Fees | 3 | 5 | — |
| Pricing Tiers | 3 | 4 | — |
| Affiliate Program | None | No public affiliate program | — |
Gusto advertises $40/mo and Jira advertises $8.15/mo. Gusto has 3 documented extra fees (recurring: +$46/mo, one-time: $50), while Jira has 5 (recurring: +$538/mo). Gusto and Jira do different jobs, so there is no like-for-like cost winner — compare what each one does before comparing price. Your real cost depends on seats and usage — use the calculator for your numbers.
Gusto has 3 documented extra fees: Per-Person Fee Scaling, Benefits Administration Add-On, State Tax Registration Fees. Recurring fees add roughly $46/mo on top of the $40/mo advertised price, plus about $50 in one-time costs.
Jira has 5 documented extra fees: 10-User Free Tier Ceiling, Marketplace Add-On Stacking, Admin & Configuration Overhead, Cloud vs Data Center Pricing Confusion, Premium Feature Gate. Recurring fees add roughly $538/mo on top of the $8.15/mo advertised price.
Choose Gusto if: Payroll, benefits, and HR platform for small businesses. Base at $40/mo + $6/person/mo, but benefits. Choose Jira if: Atlassian's issue and project tracker, the industry standard for software teams. Free for 10 users, . The right choice depends on your team size, usage volume, and which features you need most.
This comparison is compiled from public vendor pricing pages and documentation. It uses illustrative assumptions (see "Cost Comparison Summary"), not your exact seats or usage, and vendor prices change often. Confirm current prices on each vendor's site, and use our calculator with your own usage for a closer estimate. Spotted an error? Email hello@trulycritic.com.
Enter your usage to see personalized pricing for both tools
Use Free Calculator